CSCI 145 Web Page Design and Implementation

Good and Bad Critique

Keeping in mind the web page criteria we have discussed in lecture: Purpose, Content, Audience, Navigation, Speed, Style, and Maintenance, review all the 'good' and 'bad' web pages submitted by your fellow students. With these points in mind, from the review:

  1. The 'Best' of the 'Good':

    2. a. State which 'Good' pages you feel is best: _____________________

    b. Explain* briefly how this page addresses the criteria.

    c. What areas could be improved?

     

  2. The 'Worst' of the 'Bad':

    3. a. State which 'Bad' pages you feel is worst: _____________________

    b. Explain* briefly how this page addresses the criteria.

    c. What area(s) actually work?

     

  3. Using the site you selected as 'best':

    4. a. Indicate* how you would improve the site's purpose, content or attention to its audience.

    b. Indicate* how you would improve the site's navigation, speed or style.

    c. Indicate* how you, as the webmaster for this site, would be able to easily maintain the site.

     

*A brief written statement -- a paragraph or two; not pages and not just a single sentence.


Save your critique as either a text file or a Word document and email it to the instructor by midnight Tuesday 1 October 2002 with the subject line CSCI 145 Good/Bad Critique. ranger@ecst.csuchico.edu